A Hubble Diagram from ESSENCE

The Equation of State of Dark Energy

A Hubble Diagram from ESSENCE

The Equation of State of Dark Energy

Since the discovery of the accelerating expansion of the Universe in 1998, type Ia supernovae (SN Ia) have remained our most sensitive probe of dark energy. I joined the ESSENCE (Equation of State: SupErNova tracE Cosmic Expansion) project at the start of my graduate studies. ESSENCE observed over 200 SN Ia over seven years, in R and I at a median redshift of 0.4, constraining the equation of state of dark energy, w, to 10%. I was heavily involved in schedule optimization, imaging, spectroscopic follow-up, pipeline development, data reduction and analysis, and led the final analysis for my thesis. I have since been involved in cosmological studies using the Pan-STARRS telescope, and am currently Spokesperson of the LSST Dark Energy Science Collaboration.

A central challenge for the LSST era is achieving fully photometric cosmology—constraining dark energy without spectroscopic confirmation of individual supernovae. My postdoc Ayan Mitra has demonstrated a fully photometric approach to SN Ia cosmology combining joint SN+host photometric redshift fitting with photometric classification, achieving a Figure of Merit of ~150 on simulated LSST-scale samples. This work benefits from two complementary tools developed in my group: ORACLE, a real-time hierarchical deep-learning photometric classifier for LSST led by undergraduate Ved Shah, and SELDON, our foundation AI model for time-domain astrophysics. Photometric redshifts are addressed by methods such as Mantis Shrimp, a multi-survey deep learning photo-z estimator developed by former undergraduate Andrew Engel.

Building accurate SN Ia distance models is equally critical. Together with Prof. Kaisey Mandel (Cambridge), I develop hierarchical Bayesian SN Ia models. We are extending these into the rest-frame z band—which is less sensitive to dust extinction than optical bands—exploiting the synergy between the Young Supernova Experiment (YSE) and LSST DESC. A study by Erin Hayes characterizes SN Ia standardisation properties in the z band using 150 supernovae from YSE and the Foundation Supernova Survey, finding a post-standardization Hubble diagram scatter of 0.195 mag and demonstrating the z band’s potential for Rubin and Roman. We also collaborate with low-redshift surveys that anchor the distance ladder, including DEBASS (Dark Energy Bedrock All-Sky Supernova Survey), which uses DECam on CTIO to build the largest uniformly-calibrated low-z SN Ia dataset in the southern hemisphere, with over 400 spectroscopically confirmed supernovae to date. Accurate cosmology further requires precise photometric calibration: our DA white dwarf spectrophotometric standard network proved critical in the Dovekie reanalysis of the DES 5-year SN Ia sample led by Brodie Popovic, reducing photometric calibration systematic uncertainties by a factor of 1.5 over previous analyses.

We are also extending SN Ia cosmology to strongly lensed supernovae, which offer an independent route to the Hubble constant via time-delay cosmography. Working with Dr. Matt Grayling and Prof. Kaisey Mandel, we developed BayeSN-TD, a Bayesian framework that simultaneously fits SN Ia light curve parameters, gravitational lensing time delays, magnifications, and microlensing effects. BayeSN-TD is now being applied to the lensed supernova SN H0pe by my graduate student Aadya Agrawal, whose analysis of lens models for PLCK G165.7+67.0 reveals systematic magnification biases that must be corrected to achieve precision Hubble constant measurements from lensed transients.

Avatar
Gautham Narayan
Assistant Professor, Astronomy